2025 Year in Review

Explore our year in review to see the highlights and what’s ahead.

Learn more

News DTO Secures Complete Dismissal...

DTO Secures Complete Dismissal of a Putative Nationwide Product Labeling Class Action at the Pleading Stage

DTO secured a complete dismissal of a putative nationwide consumer class action brought against a global manufacturer in the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York.

The action challenged rinse-off cleansers listing retinol on the front label, claiming the products implied dermatological benefits purportedly associated with retinol that the products allegedly could not provide. DTO argued that the complaint relied on implausible assumptions about consumer expectations rather than any concrete representations on the product labeling or packaging.

The court agreed and granted DTO’s motion to dismiss the complaint in its entirety, rejecting the theory that the featuring of a single ingredient, without more, could reasonably be understood as a promise of specific results not found on the product labels. 

The decision is among the first within the Second Circuit to address these issues in the context of ingredient-based labeling claims and provides important guidance regarding the limits of consumer protection theories premised on featured ingredients.

The Latest